Toilet Training – On the toilet
Question:
Good luck with your cat’s potty training. The last thing we need at my house is someone else sharing the bathroom!
Response:
> Right. I’m a bit disappointed. This is the 1st Newsgroup I’ve gone to > where I could not get an answer to a simple question.
Obviously it’s not a simple question. If you don’t like the responses you get here, why not do a web search? Judy
Response:
> I’ve just looked in here for a possible solution to a problem. I suppose > this has been discussed before so please bear with me. > I have been training my cat to use the toilet as his litterbox. He will > urinate in it every time like it’s the most natural thing in the world. But > he just won’t jump up there to defecate. If I grab him and put him up on > the seat it’s no problem. He just won’t do it by himself. > Any ideas? > Thanks, > Darrell
I think he might object to the splashing. Or perhaps he needs a seat he can get his claws into, so he feels more secure. We had a cat who lived to be very old (nearly 25) who used to use the toilet when she felt her litterbox was in need of a change. Myself personally, I always thought we should encourage her in the practice, but since she never looked particularly comfortable, and would always look at us reproachfully if we happened to catch her in the act, we used to take our cue and change the litter post-haste. This in spite of scooping and a routine twice-weekly change.
Response:
>Right. I’m a bit disappointed. This is the 1st Newsgroup I’ve gone to >where I could not get an answer to a simple question. >I don’t care to get into a protracted argument here, but I have to ask those >who state that toilet training isn’t "Natural": What is natural about having >a spayed or neutered, nocturnal hunting, aboral dwelling carnivore living in >your house?
"Natural" doesn’t matter. If you try to force your cat to do something he doesn’t like, then you’re stressing him out. Especially, when it comes to his "restroom" habits. If you keep trying, you may end up with piss all over your jacket or shoes. DJN
Response:
>This is a big problem around here. If >people don’t agree with what you are >doing, your question goes unanswered.
This is by far the most moronic statement I’ve seen anyone post on this group in quite some time. When someone posts asking how to do something that is harmful or causes unnecessary stress to a cat, we have an OBLIGATION to dissuade them. Answering their question with advice on how to achieve a goal which causes harm or unnecessary stress to a cat is unconscionable. Megan "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." -Edmund Burke Learn The TRUTH About Declawing http://www.stopdeclaw.com Zuzu’s Cats Photo Album: http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22
Response:
>I have read it isn’t a good idea. Please >read >http://www.sniksnak.com/cathealth/toilet >html
I would like to point out here that this article is a plagiarized version of a newsgroup post I wrote a few years ago. Susie Bachman stole it. See http://groups.google.com/groups?hl=en&lr=&ie=UTF-8&th=91f55dda471ae53… Megan "The only thing necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing." -Edmund Burke Learn The TRUTH About Declawing http://www.stopdeclaw.com Zuzu’s Cats Photo Album: http://www.PictureTrail.com/zuzu22
Response:
If you do succeed, he’s not going to flush, is he? You could be setting up some awful stink problems and embarrassing situations with visitors. And what will da cat do when da bog’s in use? When a cat’s gotta go, a cat’s gotta go. I think if your cat was at all inclined to poo in the toilet, he’d already be doing it. Attempting to force the issue might damage his relationship with you. I’m not a Freudian, but I can see plenty of potential for future oddities related to potty-training-gone-wrong. The anal cat – what a thought! Behavioural reinforcement relies on encouraging elements of existing behaviour, not creating new behaviours. Cats have an already well-documented tendency to urinate into bathroom and laundry drains, plug-holes etc and the pan isn’t too far removed from that, but I think that’s as far as it goes. Try clumping cat litter. Much less fuss.
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> I’ve just looked in here for a possible solution to a problem. I suppose > this has been discussed before so please bear with me. > I have been training my cat to use the toilet as his litterbox. He will > urinate in it every time like it’s the most natural thing in the world. But > he just won’t jump up there to defecate. If I grab him and put him up on > the seat it’s no problem. He just won’t do it by himself. > Any ideas? > Thanks, > Darrell
Response:
Okay, here’s my thinking – do people teach the cat to flush too? Because the poop is just going to sit in the toilet and stink anyway. Why go thru the hassle to train him/her? If the cat likes doing it, he/she will do it. Obviously the cat doesn’t mind urinating, but doesn’t like crapping in the toilet. So give the poor thing a litter box and be done with it already! – Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > There may not even be an answer to your question, since your cat doesn’t > want to poop on the toilet. And since no one who’s answered so far, incl. > me, is "pro" making a cat use a human’s toilet, then I for one, am not going > to cudgel my brain trying to figure out a way to entice him to do it. > Especially when I know it’s only for your convenience, because you don’t > want to scoop a litter box, as people w/ cats realize is part & parcel of > having a cat. Clumping litter – which is widely available these days – > makes keeping a litter box clean super-simple. > If you had asked a question which made a whole lot more sense, re: cats, > people would’ve freely given you plenty of advice, provided there was an > answer to be had. > Cathy > — > "Staccato signals of constant information…" > ("The Boy in the Bubble") Paul Simon >Right. I’m a bit disappointed. This is the 1st Newsgroup I’ve gone to >where I could not get an answer to a simple question. >I don’t care to get into a protracted argument here, but I have to ask > those >who state that toilet training isn’t "Natural": What is natural about > having >a spayed or neutered, nocturnal hunting, aboral dwelling carnivore living > in >your house? >>OK – thank you all for your input. But let me rephrase the question. >>I’m not looking for suggestions on weather or not this is a good or >>bad idea. It is what we’re doing until our living circumstances >>change. When that happens, the cat-door gets installed and my boy >>will be free to run outside as he pleases, just like all my previous >>cats. I’m sure this may cause howls of indignation, but as you all >>stated, cats are predators, need to be cats and need to run. I’m in >>total agreement. BUT – in the meantime, I’m NOT fooling with a >>litterbox. Agreed, it’s for my convenienc, not his. But there’s a >>pet in the house and a pet owner in the house. Sorry, but I get to >>lay down the rules. >>So, does anyone have any constructive ideas on how to get "The Dude" >>to take a dump in the commode? Like I mentioned before, he’s >>perfrctly capable, I believe the boy is just giving me attitude. >>>I’ve just looked in here for a possible solution to a problem. I >>>suppose this has been discussed before so please bear with me. >>>I have been training my cat to use the toilet as his litterbox. He >>>will urinate in it every time like it’s the most natural thing in >>>the world. >>But >>>he just won’t jump up there to defecate. If I grab him and put him >>>up on the seat it’s no problem. He just won’t do it by himself. >>>Any ideas? >>>Thanks, >>>Darrell >This is a big problem around here. If people don’t agree with what you are >doing, your question goes unanswered. I don’t have anything constructive > to >say. I once had a cat who started urinating in the toilet by himself! I >have no idea what was in his mind. I’ve never had the inclination to > toilet >train since, but I understand that it’s possible.
Response:
> Right. I’m a bit disappointed. This is the 1st Newsgroup I’ve gone to > where I could not get an answer to a simple question. > I don’t care to get into a protracted argument here, but I have to ask those > who state that toilet training isn’t "Natural": What is natural about having > a spayed or neutered, nocturnal hunting, aboral dwelling carnivore living in > your house?
We have domesticated these animals over thousands of years. They are our responsibility. Spaying and neutering is the only way to keep populations down. Maybe it’s not natural, but their health can benefit from it and it is WAY more natural than euthanasia at some shelter. Not sure why you include nocturnal hunting in your list. Look, if someone here has advice and believe t- training is a good idea they are free to give it, but as you see the vast majority of cat companions here do NOT believe it is a good idea and supported their views with examples of why it can be difficult for the cat. All you did was admit this is for your own convenience. You do the math. Karen
Response:
There may not even be an answer to your question, since your cat doesn’t want to poop on the toilet. And since no one who’s answered so far, incl. me, is "pro" making a cat use a human’s toilet, then I for one, am not going to cudgel my brain trying to figure out a way to entice him to do it. Especially when I know it’s only for your convenience, because you don’t want to scoop a litter box, as people w/ cats realize is part & parcel of having a cat. Clumping litter – which is widely available these days – makes keeping a litter box clean super-simple. If you had asked a question which made a whole lot more sense, re: cats, people would’ve freely given you plenty of advice, provided there was an answer to be had. Cathy — "Staccato signals of constant information…" ("The Boy in the Bubble") Paul Simon
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> Right. I’m a bit disappointed. This is the 1st Newsgroup I’ve gone to > where I could not get an answer to a simple question. > I don’t care to get into a protracted argument here, but I have to ask those > who state that toilet training isn’t "Natural": What is natural about having > a spayed or neutered, nocturnal hunting, aboral dwelling carnivore living in > your house? > OK – thank you all for your input. But let me rephrase the question. > I’m not looking for suggestions on weather or not this is a good or > bad idea. It is what we’re doing until our living circumstances > change. When that happens, the cat-door gets installed and my boy > will be free to run outside as he pleases, just like all my previous > cats. I’m sure this may cause howls of indignation, but as you all > stated, cats are predators, need to be cats and need to run. I’m in > total agreement. BUT – in the meantime, I’m NOT fooling with a > litterbox. Agreed, it’s for my convenienc, not his. But there’s a > pet in the house and a pet owner in the house. Sorry, but I get to > lay down the rules. > So, does anyone have any constructive ideas on how to get "The Dude" > to take a dump in the commode? Like I mentioned before, he’s > perfrctly capable, I believe the boy is just giving me attitude. >> I’ve just looked in here for a possible solution to a problem. I >> suppose this has been discussed before so please bear with me. >> I have been training my cat to use the toilet as his litterbox. He >> will urinate in it every time like it’s the most natural thing in >> the world. > But >> he just won’t jump up there to defecate. If I grab him and put him >> up on the seat it’s no problem. He just won’t do it by himself. >> Any ideas? >> Thanks, >> Darrell > This is a big problem around here. If people don’t agree with what you are > doing, your question goes unanswered. I don’t have anything constructive to > say. I once had a cat who started urinating in the toilet by himself! I > have no idea what was in his mind. I’ve never had the inclination to toilet > train since, but I understand that it’s possible.
Response:
Our suggestions stand. This is a BAD idea. Karen
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text -> OK – thank you all for your input. But let me rephrase the question. I’m > not looking for suggestions on weather or not this is a good or bad idea. > It is what we’re doing until our living circumstances change. When that > happens, the cat-door gets installed and my boy will be free to run outside > as he pleases, just like all my previous cats. I’m sure this may cause > howls of indignation, but as you all stated, cats are predators, need to be > cats and need to run. I’m in total agreement. BUT – in the meantime, I’m > NOT fooling with a litterbox. Agreed, it’s for my convenienc, not his. But > there’s a pet in the house and a pet owner in the house. Sorry, but I get > to lay down the rules. > So, does anyone have any constructive ideas on how to get "The Dude" to take > a dump in the commode? Like I mentioned before, he’s perfrctly capable, I > believe the boy is just giving me attitude. > I’ve just looked in here for a possible solution to a problem. I suppose > this has been discussed before so please bear with me. > I have been training my cat to use the toilet as his litterbox. He will > urinate in it every time like it’s the most natural thing in the world. > But > he just won’t jump up there to defecate. If I grab him and put him up on > the seat it’s no problem. He just won’t do it by himself. > Any ideas? > Thanks, > Darrell
Response:
> Why are you trying to train your cat to use the toilet? What’s wrong with > him using a litterbox? > Judy
Maybe he doesn’t like the smell of the litter box. If I’m home, I clean their litter box immediately after they go to the bathroom because I can smell it. I very briefly thought about training my cats to use the toilet, but I decided against it.
Response:
>OK – thank you all for your input. But let me rephrase the question. I’m >not looking for suggestions on weather or not this is a good or bad idea. >It is what we’re doing until our living circumstances change. When that >happens, the cat-door gets installed and my boy will be free to run outside >as he pleases, just like all my previous cats. I’m sure this may cause >howls of indignation, but as you all stated, cats are predators, need to be >cats and need to run. I’m in total agreement. BUT – in the meantime, I’m >NOT fooling with a litterbox. Agreed, it’s for my convenienc, not his. But >there’s a pet in the house and a pet owner in the house. Sorry, but I get >to lay down the rules.
If a cat doesn’t want to do something, you can’t make him do it. If your try to force him, you’ll stress him out. If you don’t like fooling with a litterbox, which is minimal work, maybe you should get yourself a dog or even better a pet rock. Cats don’t buy into "I get to lay down the rules". DJN
Response:
Right. I’m a bit disappointed. This is the 1st Newsgroup I’ve gone to where I could not get an answer to a simple question. I don’t care to get into a protracted argument here, but I have to ask those who state that toilet training isn’t "Natural": What is natural about having a spayed or neutered, nocturnal hunting, aboral dwelling carnivore living in your house?
– Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > OK – thank you all for your input. But let me rephrase the question. > I’m not looking for suggestions on weather or not this is a good or > bad idea. It is what we’re doing until our living circumstances > change. When that happens, the cat-door gets installed and my boy > will be free to run outside as he pleases, just like all my previous > cats. I’m sure this may cause howls of indignation, but as you all > stated, cats are predators, need to be cats and need to run. I’m in > total agreement. BUT – in the meantime, I’m NOT fooling with a > litterbox. Agreed, it’s for my convenienc, not his. But there’s a > pet in the house and a pet owner in the house. Sorry, but I get to > lay down the rules. > So, does anyone have any constructive ideas on how to get "The Dude" > to take a dump in the commode? Like I mentioned before, he’s > perfrctly capable, I believe the boy is just giving me attitude. > I’ve just looked in here for a possible solution to a problem. I > suppose this has been discussed before so please bear with me. > I have been training my cat to use the toilet as his litterbox. He > will urinate in it every time like it’s the most natural thing in > the world. > But > he just won’t jump up there to defecate. If I grab him and put him > up on the seat it’s no problem. He just won’t do it by himself. > Any ideas? > Thanks, > Darrell
This is a big problem around here. If people don’t agree with what you are doing, your question goes unanswered. I don’t have anything constructive to say. I once had a cat who started urinating in the toilet by himself! I have no idea what was in his mind. I’ve never had the inclination to toilet train since, but I understand that it’s possible.
Response:
- Hide quoted text — Show quoted text – > OK – thank you all for your input. But let me rephrase the question. > I’m not looking for suggestions on weather or not this is a good or > bad idea. It is what we’re doing until our living circumstances > change. When that happens, the cat-door gets installed and my boy > will be free to run outside as he pleases, just like all my previous > cats. I’m sure this may cause howls of indignation, but as you all > stated, cats are predators, need to be cats and need to run. I’m in > total agreement. BUT – in the meantime, I’m NOT fooling with a > litterbox. Agreed, it’s for my convenienc, not his. But there’s a > pet in the house and a pet owner in the house. Sorry, but I get to > lay down the rules. > So, does anyone have any constructive ideas on how to get "The Dude" > to take a dump in the commode? Like I mentioned before, he’s > perfrctly capable, I believe the boy is just giving me attitude. > I’ve just looked in here for a possible solution to a problem. I > suppose this has been discussed before so please bear with me. > I have been training my cat to use the toilet as his litterbox. He > will urinate in it every time like it’s the most natural thing in > the world. > But > he just won’t jump up there to defecate. If I grab him and put him > up on the seat it’s no problem. He just won’t do it by himself. > Any ideas? > Thanks, > Darrell
This is a big problem around here. If people don’t agree with what you are doing, your question goes unanswered. I don’t have anything constructive to say. I once had a cat who started urinating in the toilet by himself! I have no idea what was in his mind. I’ve never had the inclination to toilet train since, but I understand that it’s possible.
Response:
>So, does anyone have any constructive ideas on how to get "The Dude" to take >a dump in the commode? Like I mentioned before, he’s perfrctly capable, I >believe the boy is just giving me attitude.
Darrell, the "Dude" needs a litterbox. How would you like it if you were made to go in a litterbox? Well, that’s the same as you forcing him to go on a human toilet. What’s the big deal about a litterbox? Also, cats don’t give attitude. That is only your perception. Do the cat a favor and give him a litterbox, please. Lauren =^..^= See my cats: http://www.picturetrail.com/mickey4paws/703043 To Error is Human, To be Purrfect is Feline
Response:
>OK – thank you all for your input. But let me rephrase the question. I’m >not looking for suggestions on weather or not this is a good or bad idea. >It is what we’re doing until our living circumstances change. When that >happens, the cat-door gets installed and my boy will be free to run outside >as he pleases, just like all my previous cats. I’m sure this may cause >howls of indignation, but as you all stated, cats are predators, need to be >cats and need to run. I’m in total agreement. BUT – in the meantime, I’m >NOT fooling with a litterbox.
So… what are you doing when he poops? I mean, he doesn